A public sector pay freeze is completely fair
They’ve only received a fraction of their old salaries. Many have missed out on months of work. And their pension contributions and holidays have been completely scrapped. So it is perhaps understandable that teachers, town planners and tax officials are feeling a little aggrieved. Except, er, no, sorry I made a mistake there.
That was a description of what happened to the self-employed over the last eight months, not the average public sector worker.
Instead, it now looks likely that the government will impose a pay freeze on everyone who works for the government this year, and possibly next as well. The 5.5 million affected will reportedly include the police, armed forces, teachers and civil servants. Predictably, the unions are up in arms, as are the Labour Party, and we will be hearing a lot in the coming days about the sacrifices made by ‘frontline workers’.
But the truth is, the public sector has already been largely insulated from the economic impact of this crisis, and there is no reason it should not share some of the burden of getting out of it.
Whether Rishi Sunak, the Chancellor, goes ahead with a public sector pay freeze remains to be seen. When he, or more specifically the guy next door, is faced with a choice between some bad headlines and writing a big cheque he usually ends up handing over whatever amount of money is needed to fix the problem. But, in reality, a pay freeze is the right decision. Why? For two reasons.
First, the public sector has largely been insulated from the economic impact of the Covid-19 crisis. Everyone has been paid in full. Pensions and holidays have been protected. No redundancies have been made. True, some people have been working harder – in parts of the NHS most obviously – but others have had very little to do while the country ground to a halt.
Compare that to the private sector. Furloughs have to some degree protected employees – although many of them have only been receiving 80 per cent of their old salaries and have had to reckon with the grim reality that their company may make them redundant. But entrepreneurs and small businesses have been badly hit, with many taking on huge debts as they struggle to keep closed businesses alive, and face big bills for coping with capricious, fast-changing rules about whether they can open and what protections they need to put in place.
And the self-employed, almost as big a slice of the workforce as the public sector, have been shamefully treated, with a ramshackle rescue package that has plunged many of them into deep financial trouble.
Next, it might not be an urgent priority in the middle of the epidemic, but sooner or later we are going to have to pay for this crisis. We can’t carry on borrowing 20 per cent of GDP indefinitely.
The harsh truth is that as a country, along with most others, we are 10 per cent poorer than we were a year ago. At some point that will have to be reflected in incomes and living standards. The private sector, as always, will take most of the hit. But the burden should be shared by everyone. In truth, a pay freeze is completely fair – even if most public sector workers will struggle to get that.
THE Scottish and British governments have been urged to commit to ending fossil fuel extraction after Denmark announced a ban on North Sea drilling this week.
Simple and cowardly short-termism is a major reason for the UK’s dismal performance.
The Government stunned world-leading businesses in September with its plan to end VAT-free shopping for tourists in the new year.
A parliamentary committee found about 50 billion pounds worth of cash in circulation is not being spent, and blasted the bank for...
Charissa Ball and Yan Li have recently published the article “Regulation of Virtual Asset Service Providers in the British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands and Bermuda”.
The first doses of the newly approved coronavirus vaccine made by Pfizer arrived in Britain on Thursday night, the shipment packed...
A better-looking home screen, Do Not Disturb, longer battery life and more reliable unlocking are all instantly achievable on your...
Fauci also confirmed that he accepted Biden’s offer to become the president-elect’s chief medical adviser.
City’s education chief acknowledges the possibility of increased oversight in Legislative Council meeting.
Preliminary talks are underway to begin testing the e-CNY in the special administrative region of Hong Kong.
Hong Kong social enterprise restaurant trains disabled and disadvantaged
Hong Kong’s Legislative Council approved on Friday engineering and infrastructure studies for a government plan to build vast artificial...
The Christmas display and festive atmosphere in Hong Kong is one of best in Asia. Harbour City is the largest and most diverse...
Get a taste of Hong Kong without leaving home.
Officials are calling off the pyrotechnics over Victoria Harbour, as well as the annual Lunar New Year parade in February, due to the fourth wave of Covid-19 infections.
Fixed penalty of HK$5,000 takes effect next Friday and targets those who violate rules on public gatherings, mask wearing and testing.
The U.K. is granting the most special travel documents to Hong Kong residents since the 1997 handover, bolstering predictions of...
China has seized the global lead in tackling Big Tech lending which threatens to destabilise finance in multiple jurisdictions.
Airline did not consult unions on restructuring, lay-offs, saying changes are vital to ensure survival.
Judge rules 31-year-old Lam Yik-sing ‘completely abandoned’ his duty as an officer when he failed to intervene in the assault.
Female genital mutilation is considered a violation of human rights by the UN, and is illegal in many countries. The procedure...
First came Zhaxi Dingzhen, a Tibetan herder from southwest China whose rugged looks wowed internet users. Now comes a horse rider...
Inquest unearths previously unseen footage that appears to show Alex Chow’s final moments, and student’s father welcomes ‘huge step towards truth’.
China’s top body overseeing Hong Kong says sentences handed to Wong and others do not compensate for their crimes against the nation.