Ministers could be stopped from using self-destructing messages to conduct government business, following a legal challenge supported by an alliance of transparency campaigners and university archivists.
WhatsApp recently introduced the option for users to make messages permanently disappear for both the sender and the recipient after seven days. Its privacy-focussed rival, Signal, used by many Conservative MPs, has had a similar function for some time.
There are growing concerns that politicians and special advisers could be using such features to avoid accountability. Lawyers are now gearing up to bring a judicial review against the use of automatically disappearing messages, on the basis that using such functions makes it impossible to carry out the required legal checks about whether a message should be archived for posterity.
Cori Crider, a director of the campaigning law group Foxglove, said: “It’s not appropriate to conduct government business on disappearing-message platforms.
“The basic point is that privacy is for the citizen and transparency is for the government. This government is amassing more and more data on all of us and we have less and less information on them. That has the democratic bargain exactly backwards.”
Almost a decade ago, the Information Commissioner’s Office declared that private emails and text messages used to discuss government business were still subject to freedom of information requests. This followed a dispute between the Financial Times journalist Chris Cook and Dominic Cummings, then an adviser to Michael Gove, after Cummings was found to be directing individuals to contact him via his private email rather than his official work account. Gove and Cummings said they were discussing Conservative party matters, which were not covered by the rules.
However, the ruling has proved difficult to enforce, with many politicians and advisers simply being more discreet about their use of private communications accounts. To complicate matters, government business is increasingly conducted on encrypted messaging apps such as WhatsApp, which makes it harder to obtain records of the decision-making process. Some officials have also been known to use accounts on the highly encrypted ProtonMail service to avoid scrutiny.
While an individual could be prosecuted for destroying messages after a freedom of information request is received, the recent arrival of simple-to-use self-destructing messaging functions in popular apps has raised new concerns about legal processes.
The case builds on work by Richard Ovenden, who is currently Bodley’s librarian at the University of Oxford and president of the Digital Preservation Commission. He has said that politicians’ use of disappearing messages leaves them “unable to be scrutinised by the public who they are employed to serve” and affects both citizens and future historians.
The lawyers argue that existing legislation dating from 1958 requiring documents to be archived does not distinguish between formats, whether they are formal letters or disappearing digital messages.
Crider is bringing the case on behalf of the Citizens, a non-profit political group that has run campaigns including an investigation of the government’s distribution of pandemic-related contracts and the setting up of a rival Facebook oversight board. A crowdfunding campaign is expected to help with the costs of the case.
A spokesperson for the Citizens said: “Government business is being conducted under a cloak of secrecy enabled by the tech platforms. We desperately need to challenge what we believe is a clear breach of the law on behalf of both Britain’s investigative journalists and its future historians.”
A Cabinet Office spokesperson said: “Records of official communications are retained in accordance with the relevant publicly published guidance. There are appropriate arrangements already in place and this is kept under periodic review.”
Legal challenge seeks to stop ministers sending disappearing messages
Self-destructing messages are undemocratic, say transparency campaigners preparing judicial review
CNN Director Admits on video that they faked Trump and Biden coverage as a “propaganda” to “take down Trump”.
CNN Director: “[Trump’s] hand was shaking...We brought in so many medical people to tell a story that was all speculation -- that...
The main landlord in London’s Canary Wharf financial district is considering scrapping plans for a new office skyscraper and building a 60-story apartment tower instead.
The divide between rich and poor has been widening, even during a global pandemic; let’s at least consider whether corporations and the wealthy should contribute more.
Hong Kong’s public broadcasting service purged of democratic voices: journalist who challenged WHO with Taiwan question resigns
The host of an English language news and current affairs program on Hong Kong’s public broadcasting service who questioned a WHO...
The combined value of super-prime properties sold in the British capital climbed in 2020 to $3.7 billion (3.1 billion euros).
Teaching materials ignore the arrests of dozens of peaceful dissidents and pro-democracy lawmakers under the law.
Hong Kong has selected AlipayHK, Octopus, Tap & Go and WeChat Pay HK as e-payment providers for its HKD 5,000 digital voucher scheme.
HSBC on Monday reached an agreement to share documents with lawyers for Huawei Chief Financial Officer Meng Wanzhou following her...
Hong Kongers' interest in UK property remained strong despite the effects of the pandemic, creating a preference that is set to stay in 2021.
Chinese online insurance technology firm Waterdrop Inc is receiving pushback from domestic regulators on its planned U.S. initial...
The Office of the Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data in Hong Kong (PCPD) has reached out to Clubhouse over the alleged data leak.
Chief Executive Carrie Lam says city residents will be allowed to fly back on any Hong Kong-bound flights from Britain from early May.
Secretary for Justice Teresa Cheng highlights benefits of being involved in Beijing’s 14th five-year plan during online seminar with city’s legal community.
Under revised scheme, 5,000 patacas can be transferred to digital wallets supported by eight mobile payment operators, while purchases...
The officer is one of three people suspected of running the underground poker room, while four stand accused of working as dealers.
Chief executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor said the government is thinking of letting its residents who are now in Chinese provinces...
Quarantine requirement to be dropped for mainland visitors to Hong Kong from mid-May, subject to screening conditions; city confirms 13 new cases.
Minister says inciting voters to leave ballot papers blank could violate Basic Law, but analysts warn banning the practice could...
It was an occasion to rejoice for children and their parents as more students were allowed back in schools yesterday after the Easter break.
Expats and others planning to travel are among the relative few to be vaccinated, as most choose to ‘wait and see’.
Authorities are considering making it mandatory for civil servants to complete training courses in the mainland during their three-year...